...... |
...
...TUBERCULOUS
PERICARDITIS
REPORT CASE
...Doina Butcovan¹, Catalina Arsenescu²,
Gr. Tinica², E. Sandica², V. Diaconescu²,
Cristina Prisecariu², Cleopatra Borza³,
Costel & C. Grigoras¹, GIM Georgescu²
¹UMF – Iasi, Department of Pathology
²Centrul de cardiologie Iasi
³DSP - Brasov
...
...
SUMMARY
Objective: The tuberculosis is responsible for 40% of cases
of acute pericarditis, 7% from cases of cardiac tamponade, and 6% of cases
of constrictive pericarditis. We report a case of tuberculous pericarditis
diagnosed at Cardiology Center Iasi.
Material and Methods: The study was made on surgical biopsic specimen,
obtained by making a pleuro-pericardial window. The diagnosis was established
by using routine morphological techniques.
Results: The microscopical examination revealed characteristic
morphological aspects corresponding to granulomatous inflammation of tuberculous
origin represented by multiple granulomas with Langhans type giant cells
and extensive caseous necrosis in a fibrotic pericardium, much thickened
due to a long disease evolution.
Conclusions: The study revealed the importance of establishing the
etiological disease diagnosis for indicating a target effective treatment.
Key words: tuberculous pericarditis, Langhans giant cells, caseous
necrosis.
Abbreviations: Z-N=Ziehl-Neelsen, Myc.tbc.=Mycobacterium tuberculosis,
P=pericarditis.
RESUME
Le but de travail: La tuberculose est responsable de 40 % des
cases de pericardite aigue, 7 % des cases de la tamponade cardiaque, et
6 % des cases de pericardite constrictive. Nous rapportons un cas de pericardite
tuberculose diagnostique au Centre de Cardiologie Iasi.
Material et methode: L’etude a ete fait sur des pieces chirurgicales
obtenues par une breche pleuro-pericardique. Le diagnostique
a ete etabli par l’utilisation des techniques usuales.
Resultates: L’examen microscopique a releve les aspectes morphologiques
caracteristiques corespondent a l’inflammation granulomateuse tuberculeuses
represantee par : granulomes multiples avec des cellules geantes
de type Langhans et de la necrose caseuse extensive dans un pericarde fibreuse,
epaisse a cause d’une evolution prolongee de la maladie.
Conclusion: L’etude a releve l’importance d’un diagnostique
etiologique de la maladie pour l’indication d’un traitement specifique.
Mots clefs: pericardite tuberculose, cellules geantes de type Langhans,
necrose caseuse.
Abbreviations: Z-N=Ziehl-Neelsen, Myc.tbc.=Mycobacterium tuberculeuse,
P=pericardite.
INTRODUCTION
The tuberculous pericarditis
is a pericardial inflammatory disease caused by infections with Mycobacterium
tuberculosis (Myc.tbc.) representing 4% from all cases of pericarditis.
If the tuberculous pericarditis mortality was of 100% in the pre-antituberculous
drug era, it was decreased at 40% by using antituberculous drugs, and today,
the tuberculous cases are increasing due to Myc.tbc. drug resistance (1).
The tuberculous pericarditis is producing at 1% of patients
with active tuberculosis, 50% from them having an active pulmonary disease
at presentation. The way of dissemination of the infection at patients
without active pulmonary disease it is supposed to be secondary of the
breaking in the pericardial space of the mediastinal lymph node with tuberculous
limfadenitis (2).
There are known 4 clinical syndromes
of pericardial disease represented by acute pericarditis, pericardial effusions,
constrictive pericarditis and constrictive pericarditis with pericardial
effusion (3). Morphologically, there are described 3 evolutive stages of
the tuberculous pericarditis, such as: acute pericarditis (fibrinous or
sero-fibrinous pericarditis), subacute pericarditis (granulomatous inflammation
with caseous necrosis), and chronic pericarditis including 3 morphological
subtypes (the thickening of the pericardium through pericardial fibrosis,
the pericardial fibrosis with the focal obliteration of the pericardial
cavity, and constrictive pericarditis) (3).
The diagnosis is difficult consisting in a variety of
tests: positive Myc.tbc. cultures made from pericardial fluid (30-75% of
cases are positive), positive smear stainings for acid fast bacilli made
from pericardial fluid, polimerase chain reaction for Myc. tbc. ADN (is
of great diagnostic advantage), positive tuberculinic test (is suggestive
for diagnosis), positive treatment response at anti-tuberculous chemotherapy,
identification of necrotizing granulomas on the pericardial biopsy, being
diagnostic even in the abscence of the positive Ziehl-Neelsen (Z-N) smear
staining, and typically, the pericardial fluid is sero-citrin with lymphocytosis,
which is suggestive for tuberculosis (4, 5). In evolution, all patients
with tuberculous pericarditis develop constrictive pericarditis (P) without
treatment (6). The prevalence of the pericardial fibrosis decreases at
40% at patients with antituberculous drugs. Although the medical cure is
effective in the most cases, is recommended early pericardectomy at all
tuberculous pericarditis patients, due to the high risk of constrictive
pericarditis (7, 8).
MATERIAL AND METHODS
In a 51 years old female patient presenting
with progressive dispnea and malaise, and having the previous diagnosis
of pleuro-pericarditis of unknown etiology, established three months ago,
the repeated hospital admission were indicated for draining the pleuro-pericardial
fluid. The surgical biopsic specimen, obtained through a pleuro-pericardial
window, was fixed in buffered 10% formalin for 12 hours and quite totally
sampled. Samples were processed using routine paraffin embedding, cutting
(5 mm) and hematoxilin-eosin (HE) and Van Gieson (VG) staining.
RESULTS
The study represents a case
report of an unknown cause pericarditis diagnosed in a 51 years old female
patient presenting repeated hospital admission for paracenthesis.
The laboratory tests were not relevant for Myc.tbc. etiology, showing a
slight leucocytosis without lymphocytosis and negative Z-N smear staining.
The chest X-ray evidentiated a large heart, a right micronodular apical
sequelae and a pleural fluid reaction, predominant at the right base. The
echocardiography didn’t show signs of cardiac tamponade but revealed a
moderate postero-inferior and apical pericardial fluid.
The surgically intervention evidentiated
a tickened fibrous pericardium and moderate effusion requiring a pleuro-pericardial
drainage and a pleuro-pericardial window. The histological examination
of the surgical biopsic specimen revealed a thick pericardium through an
extensive fibrosis enclosing multiple specific tuberculous granulomas,
with giant cells of Langhans type and large areas
of caseous necrosis permitting the diagnosis of subacute tuberculous pericarditis
with chronic fibrotic evolution. The histology is illustrated by few photogrames
showing: a thickened pericardium with areas of fibrosis and mononuclear
inflammatory infiltrate and zones of dense fibrosis with few granulomas
and a chronic inflammation (Fig.1); aggregates
of macrophages and few giant cells (Fig.2)
and large areas of caseous necrosis (Fig. 3) representing
tuberculous necrotising granulomatous lesion.
DISCUSSIONS AND CONCLUSIONS
The present study describes
a particular case of tuberculous pericarditis, with a long evolution presenting
with atypical signs for a specific etiology. Symmers (7) considers that
the tuberculous pericarditis account for 4% of all cases of acute pericarditis,
and in some of the older series, for approximately 6% of all cases of cardiac
tamponade. Silver (10) reported also that the Myc. tbc. was found
as the most frequent cause of pericardial disease, this etiology reflecting
the diseases spectrum prevalating in an area. The two authors observed
that the frequency of the tuberculosis has been progressively decreasing
since the-mid-1950, due to the appearance on the market of anti-tuberculous
drugs and also, an increasing in the last few years, this fact has been
linked to the appearance of the multi-drug resistant Myc. tuberculosis.
Colin (1) noted that the pericardium may
be involved in tuberculosis usually in association with foci of tuberculosis
elsewhere in the body, most commonly in the lung, as in our case. Symmers
(7) showed that the tuberculous pericarditis occurred in approximately
2% of cases of pulmonary tuberculosis. Discussing about the way of dissemination,
in our case, we appreciated that the spreading of the Myc.tbc. was made
through lymphatic way from an old pleuro-pulmonary tuberculosis, demonstrated
by an apical nodular sequelae and a moderate tuberculous pleuresis. We
couldn’t demonstrate other tuberculous foci elsewhere in the body.
Referring to the general clinical manifestations
and morphological reactions, a good review of the subject has been published
by Hageman (9) who admitted that most patients with pericardial tuberculosis
were in in the third to fifth decade of life, having an history of typical
symptoms such as shortness of breath, coughing and weight loss and most
of them having a positive tuberculosis test, except if they have skin test
anergy. Radiographically, the signs of the pericardial disease didn’t differ
too much, at our patient, from that reported in the literature, this examination
being helpful in cases of pericardial effusions. As Symmers’ appreciation
(7), the echocardiography was in our case the most helpful diagnostic non-invasive
technique in detecting of the pericardial effusion.
Silver (10) considers that a definitive diagnosis
may be established by isolating the organism from pericardial fluid or
pericardial biopsy, but the probability of obtaining a diagnosis is greatest,
if both fluid and biopsy specimens are examined in the early effusive stages;
we didn’t obtain a positive Z-N histological staining for Myc. tuberculosis.
Morphologically, it is well known,
that the pericardium reacts to the various agents in a limited way. The
basic known changes consist of fibrin, fluid and cells; the cellular reaction
is various depending on the organism. Waller (6) described 3 morphological
stages in the evolution of the tuberculous pericarditis: stage 1 (sero-fibrinous
stage), corresponding with acute phase from actual Silver classification
(10);
stage 2, corresponding with subacute phase from Silver
classification, is characterised by effusion and thickened pericardium,
appearance similar with our case; Waller appreciated that tubercles may
be found, too; stage 3, corresponding with chronic phase from Silver classification,
is defined by constriction and calcification. The effusion becomes less
and the pericardium is thicker and may be fibro-caseous. In time this appearance
disappears and a firm fibrous tissue remains. In that way the healing by
fibrosis may lead to adhesions.
Colin (1) found 10 patients with acute
granulomatous P. In 9 patients, the resected pericardial tissue showed
caseating granulomata consistent with tuberculosis. In our case, we found
various appearances corresponding histologically with 2 stage showing a
relative stratification of the lesions with intermixing borders, such as:
a delicate in incontinous fibrinous exudate, continued by irregular organising
fibrotic zone, enclosing small or large caseous necrotic areas with small
tuberculous granulomas at their periphery. In our opinion, the significant
fibrotic component demonstrated a long duration of the disease, and in
the same time the important effusive component, was a prove of the persistence
of the etiological agent. This extensive fibrotic component made difficult
to identify it by using histological specific Z-N staining. Silver (10)
appreciated that Myc. tuberculosis was demonstrable only in 6% of cases
who underwent pericardectomy for chronic P.
Silver (10) and Colin (1) also appreciated
that the constrictive P. develops finally, in almost all patients with
untreated tuberculous P. requiring pericardectomy. They also indicated
an early combined medical therapy with anti-tuberculous drugs and steroids,
for decreasing mortality and resulting in more rapid clinical improvement.
In the Symmers’ reports (7) the mortality rate for pericardial tuberculosis
was ranging from 3 to 40%, depending on the type of the treatment administered
with or without steroids, and medical versus surgical.
REFFERENCES
1. Colin MB. Pericarditis. In: Colin MB Ed. Heart Pathology.
Churchill Livingstone 1980, 265-272.
2. Blomm J. Pericarditis. In: Sternberg SS. Diagnostic Surgical Pathology.
Ed. Raven Press, 1944: 1216-1217.
3. Virmani R. Tuberculous Pericarditis. In: Allen Burke and Renu Virmani.
Atlas of Cardiovascular Pathology. Ed. AFIP. Washington DC 1966: 104-106.
4. Gilbert E. Pericarditis. In: Silverberg SG. Principles and Practice
of Surgical Pathology and Cytopathology. Ed. Churchill Livingstone 1997,
1318-1321.
5. Brisson NA. Rapid diagnosis of tuberculosis by amplification of
mycobacterial DNA in clinical samples. Lancet 1989; 2: 1069-1071.
6. Waller BF. Pericardial Disease. In: Waller BF. Pathology of the
Heart and great vessels, The Mosby Company, 1998, 1173-1178.
7. Symmers WSC. The pericardium. In: Symmers WSC. Cardiovascular
System. Springer-Verlag, New York, 1980, 672-675.
8. Muir P, Nicholson F et al: Chronic relapsing pericarditis. Lancet
I: 804-7, 1989.
9. Hageman JH. Tuberculous pericarditis: a long term analysis of 44
cases. N Engl J Med, 1964; 270: 327-764.
10. Silver MD. Pericarditis. In Silver MD. Gotlieb AI. Eds. Cardiovascular
Pathology. Churchill Livingstone 2001, 385-389.
..
..
|
.
..... |